Lighting test in class

Today in class we decided on the lighting we wanted for our studio shoot which we decided is going to be our street poster. The lighting we want is soft with soft shadows in the background with either white or a soft grey.
We have changed to having 3 members of our band, just to make things easier when it comes to shooting so our members will be 2 boys and a girl.

Here is the initial lighting we thought of, stemming from the butterfly light test we did in a previous class.

And this is the image we used as a guide to what lighting we want:

From this we could see that the lighting has come from above because of the shadowing underneath her nose and around the eyes. So we had to change our lighting plan when we completed the test.